The stocky all-rounder Samit Patel made 104 to steer the tourists to 426 in their first innings on the final day of the three-day tour opener against India 'A' at the Brabourne stadium in Mumbai.
The match petered out into a draw as the hosts, trailing by 57 runs on the first innings, scored 124-4 in their second knock by stumps with Ajinkya Rahane making 54.
England's weakness against the turning ball was exposed when part-time spinner Yuvraj Singh grabbed a five-wicket haul to follow his 59 in the first innings.
Patel, a right-hand batsman who bowls left-arm spin, hit 14 boundaries during his five-hour vigil that could hand him the number six Test spot ahead of Eoin Morgan and Jonny Bairstow.
Both Morgan and Bairstow, who were ignored for the opening match, are likely to play in the remaining two practice matches ahead of the Ahmedabad Test.
Patel made two Test appearances against Sri Lanka earlier this year, scoring 40 runs and taking three wickets, but was ignored for the subsequent home Tests against the West Indies and South Africa.
The Nottinghamshire star, who turns 28 this month, is a regular member of England's limited-overs squad with 31 one-day and 14 Twenty20 internationals under his belt.
Alastair Cook and Patel added 16 runs to the overnight score of 286-4 when the captain was caught behind off seamer Ashok Dinda for 119.
The pair put on 169 for the fifth wicket after the tourists were struggling at 133-4 midway through the afternoon session on Wednesday.
Patel, who resumed on 82, was content to play second fiddle as Matt Prior hammered 51 of the 65 runs they added for the sixth wicket before both fell to Yuvraj in the same over.
The tourists take on Mumbai 'A' in another three-day game from Saturday and then play state side Haryana in a four-day match in Ahmedabad from November 8 ahead of the four-Test series.
India 'A' 1st innings: 369 (Abhinav Mukund 73, Yuvraj Singh 59, Manoj Tiwary 93, Irfan Pathan 46, Graeme Swann 3-90, Tim Bresnan 3-59)
England 1st innings: 426 (Alastair Cook 119, Jonathan Trott 56, Kevin Pietersen 23, Samit Patel 104, Yuvraj Singh 5-94)
India'A' 2nd innings: 124-4 (Ajinkya Rahane 54)
Photos: Shraddha Kapoor, Kim Sharma at 'Haseena Parkar' screening
Mumbai to Goa train: First look at the glass-top Vistadome coach
Shuttler Ashwini Ponnappa keeps it short and sexy on social media
Photos: Narendra Modi, others at Marshal Arjan Singh's funeral
Photos: Sussanne Khan and Nimrat Kaur spotted at a spa in Juhu