The couple was spotted wearing matching aviators and holding hands, when they arrived at the AMC Loews Lincoln Square, People magazine reported.
After the movie, the duo stopped briefly into a MAC cosmetics store close by.
Later in the evening, the Hollywood stars visited the Blue Hill restaurant, where they celebrated their August 10 engagement in 2012.
A source told the publication that the pair looked very happy.
The pair, along with two other friends, left the restaurant hand in hand once again, at around 11 p.m.
In pictures: Chris Gayle and his multiple records in cricket
Photos: Varun Dhawan, Alia Bhatt, Esha Gupta at Mumbai airport
Spotted: Nora Fatehi and Swara Bhaskar at a studio in Mumbai
J. Jayalalithaa birth anniversary: Her life in pictures
Photos: 'Badri' Varun Dhawan woos his 'Dulhania' Alia Bhatt