Don't act like a grandmother: HC to Censor Board on 'Udta Punjab'
Slap on the wrist for Censor Board! Bombay High Court orders CBFC to pass 'Udta Punjab' with 'A' certificate and only one cut and three disclaimers by the filmmakers
The Bombay High Court on Monday cleared the Bollywood film 'Udta Punjab' for release with one cut and three disclaimers by the filmmakers in Mumbai.
The decision of HC overruled the CBFC recommendations of 13 cuts. (Here's the full list of 13 cuts)
The film's co-producer Anurag Kashyap welcomed the court ruling and said 'our stand has been vindicated on the issue'.
A division bench comprising Justice S.C. Dharmadhikari and Justice Shalini Phansalkar-Joshi also directed the Central Board of Film Certification to issue an 'A' Certificate to the film which is scheduled for release on Friday.
"The court has set aside the 13 cuts demanded by the CBFCs' Revising Committee and cleared the film for release with one cut -- that of the hero shown urinating in public -- which we had already agreed to cut earlier," said a lawyer for the film producers who had filed the case.
He added that the court has ordered the CBFC to issue an 'A' (Adult) Certificate to facilitate the film's scheduled June 17 release.
Earlier, observing that the controversial Bollywood film 'Udta Punjab' did not have anything that questions the country's sovereignty, the Bombay High Court came down heavily on the CBFC saying it has no powers to 'censor' films. (Read more)
The word 'censor' is not there in the board's name (CBFC) and it should use its powers as per the Constitution and earlier Supreme Court verdicts, Justice Dharmadhikari and Justice Phansalkar-Joshi observed.
They further pointed out that the central theme of the film depicts the drug menace prevalent in a place (Punjab) and the worth of a film should be considered in its entirety instead of isolated factors like songs, dialogues, lines, words, etc, so there was no justification for deleting the word "Punjab" and other cities in that state.
It should be left open to the creative person to choose the backdrop, the theme and settings for the film and nobody can dictate to him how to make the film which is the underlying key to creative freedom, they further observed.
Here's what HC said:
>> CBFC not empowered by law to censor films as the word censor is not included in the Cinematograph Act
>> We don't find anything in the film that shows Punjab in bad light or affects the sovereignty or integrity of India as claimed by CBFC.
>> Creative freedom should not be unnecessarily curbed and nobody can dictate to a filmmaker about the content of his film.
>> CBFC's powers to cut, delete or change scenes must be consistently in consonance with provisions of the Constitution and Supreme Court orders.
>> HC clears 'Udta Punjab' release, but directs filmmaker to delete urination scene and asks for a revised disclaimer.
>> HC tells CBFC to not act like a grandmother, and change as per times.
Co-produced by Kashyap and directed by Abhishek Chaubey, "Udta Punjab" stars Shahid Kapoor, Alia Bhatt, Kareena Kapoor Khan and Diljit Dosanjh.
Among other things, Kashyap accused CBFC chairman Pahlaj Nihalani of bullying and deliberately not certifying the film slated for release on June 17.
While the CBFC at one point demanded 89 cuts in the film, its Revising Committee brought down the number to 13 on June 6 -- which has now been struck down by the court -- paving the way for its release on Friday with one cut and three disclaimers.
-with inputs from Gaurav Dubey and agencies