Gauri Shinde on reports of 'Dear Zindagi' being a replica of Canadian show: People never happy with others' success

Updated: Dec 07, 2016, 10:24 IST | Mohar Basu

In last few days, reports of Gauri Shinde's 'Dear Zindagi' being a 'replica' of Canadian television series 'Being Erica' have surfaced. Here's what she has to say about it

A still from 'Dear Zindagi'
A still from 'Dear Zindagi'

In the last few days, reports of Gauri Shinde's second directorial venture 'Dear Zindagi' being a 'replica' of Canadian television series 'Being Erica' have surfaced. Parallels were drawn between Alia Bhatt's Kiara and Erica (played by Erin Karpluck), and her dimaag ka doctor played by Shah Rukh Khan is said to have been inspired by Dr Tom (played by Michael Ray). Even the dialogues like 'har tooti hui cheez jodi ja sakti hai' have been likened to Dr Tom's 'whatever it is that you are unhappy about, I can fix it'.

Kiara's boyfriends played by Angad Bedi and Ali Zafar, too, can be found in the series, the former 'too good to be dumped' named Ethan and the latter, 'a charming musician' named Kai who woos Erica in front of scores of people. However, unlike the series, the film doesn't take the time travel route. The parallels were too glaring to go unnoticed.

Gauri Shinde
Gauri Shinde

However, when hitlist got in touch with Gauri, she was taken aback by the rumours. "Huh? I don't even know what series you are talking about. But, yes, it is a good try on the part of whoever wants to bring this movie ['Dear Zindagi'] down. Why don't people watch the show, since I haven't, and decide for themselves? I don't read rubbish. There is so much baseless crap out there and I can't respond to everything," she responded via text message.

Of course, it is déjà vu for Gauri — when her first film, 'English Vinglish' (2012), which marked Sridevi's comeback to the screen after almost 15 years, had released, similar reports had emerged. It was said to be an outtake of 'Mind Your Language', the successful late 70s television series about a motley group of people learning English.


Still from 'Being Erica'

Recalling the rumours, the director retorts, "Trust me, people are never happy with others' success. They tried to do the same with 'English Vinglish'. But, all this doesn't bother me at all."

Second time for Alia

Udta Punjab

Udta Punjab starring Shahid Kapoor, Alia Bhatt and Diljit Dosanjh, too, faced plagiarism allegations after its release. The story resembled Ben Elton's 2002 novel High Society. Shahid’s character, Tommy Singh, was found similar to the novel’s protagonist Tommy Hanson, a famous artiste who battles drug abuse. Alia’s character too was similar to Jessie -- a 17-year-old Scottish girl, who is forced into prostitution after she flees her native place; she escapes from the clutches of her pimp and fights addiction. Diljit’s Sartaj was along the lines of a cop fighting for justice. The makers, however, did not officially deny the charges.

Sign up for all the latest news, top galleries and trending videos from Mid-day.com

Subscribe

Alia Bhatt and Gauri Shinde talk about love and 'Dear Zindagi'

This website uses cookie or similar technologies, to enhance your browsing experience and provide personalised recommendations. By continuing to use our website, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy. OK