Man asks waiters of Mumbai restaurant for onions, gets a black eye

Published: 02 December, 2013 07:52 IST | Vinay Dalvi |

When Mayur Jadhav asked for an extra plate of onions for a group of seven at a restaurant, they were lectured on the rising prices. The argument soon turned ugly and ended with him getting thrashed

While politicians are gifting chief ministers onions as gag gifts,the common man is getting a black eye from the prized meal garnish. Recently, the management of Shalimar, a popular restaurant on Mohammed Ali Road, ganged up on a bunch of customers, after they demanded an extra plate of onions.

Mayur Jadhav
Left with a bitter taste: Mayur Jadhav received 12 stitches near his eye while another one of his friends was bruised. Pic/Milind Karekar

According to the Pydhonie police, the incident took place after 11 pm on Friday, when 23-year-old Mayur Pirati Jadhav, a resident of BIT chawl in Mazgaon, Byculla went to Shalimar restaurant to have dinner with six of his friends and relatives. They ordered some chicken starters and raan biryani.

Said Jadhav, “For the whole meal, we were served only one plate of onion, and since it was not enough for our group we requested the waiter to bring another. He said yes to us but never returned to our table. After a while, we reminded him again but he started talking about the increased prices of onion.”

Jadhav continued, “We informed him that the prices had stabilised, but he got agitated and snapped at me, saying, ‘Don’t preach to me about onion prices’. Then another waiter joined the altercation and he was even more aggressive than this one; he caught me by my collar.”

Soon, a scuffle broke out between the two groups. The waiters rushed to shut all the exits to the diner and asked the other customers to leave, which they were happy to do.

Jadhav, who works at Prince Aly Khan Hospital in Byculla, said, “They wanted to lock us all up and beat us good. One of the waiters threw an empty glass towards me which hit me near my eye and I started bleeding.”

According to the police complaint, the livid waiters turned on Jadhav’s relatives when they tried to intervene. But once the restaurant employees saw that Jadhav had started bleeding, they realised the fracas had spun out of control and decided to break it off by throwing Jadhav and company out of the diner. A battered Jadhav, accompanied by the others, went straight to Pydhonie police station and lodged an FIR.

Following preliminary investigations and questioning, the police arrested the 21-year-old restaurant manager Mohammad Rizwan Ziyauddhin Ahmed, a resident of Bandra, and 31-year-old waiter Brijbaan Asaram Singh who resides on Mohammed Ali Road.

The two were booked under sections 326 (voluntarily causing grievous hurt by dangerous weapons or means), 323 (voluntarily causing hurt), 504 (insult with intent to provoke breach of peace) and 34 (acts done by several persons in furtherance of a common intention) of the Indian Penal Code.

“We have registered a case and arrested the accused,” said senior inspector Dinesh Ahire of Pydhonie police station. The police have the duo’s custody till December 3.

Meanwhile, Jadhav received 12 stitches near his right eye. “My eye was saved by a hair’s breadth. Had they hit me a little below, my eye would have been damaged,” he said.

Are we tempera-mental?
Doctors and sociologists who have been studying such rage-related crimes say that we are turning into an unstable mob because of a shaky economy and our individuated, high-speed lives. “Surging inflation, rising cost of living and bad relationships due to emotional disconnect in a fast life are factors that have created anger among people. Because of this, a small provocation can magnify into a full-blown brawl among people, specially on roads. Nobody is ready to listen to sense,” said psychiatrist Harish Shetty. 

The Other Side
MLA Abu Azmi, president of the state unit of the Samajwadi Party, who co-owns Shalimar along with his sister, said, “The restaurant’s staff and proprietors are quality-conscious people and have put a lot of effort to make it this popular. I am sure the owners were not present when the incident took place. This episode will cast a bad light on the restaurant’s image. I will see to it that such things don’t happen in future.” 

Food fights
Gang kills truck driver, loots onions
Nov 2013:

Lucknow: A gang of highway robbers looted a truck ferrying onions and killed the driver and cleaner of the vehicle. The same gang had also killed a truck driver in Azamgarh, UP, and looted the consignment of tomatoes that the vehicle was carrying.

Vendor shot at for omitting onions in omelette
Sept 2013:

ETAH, uttar pradesh: A man shot at a street side egg vendor when the latter forgot to add chopped onions to the omelette he had served. The vendor was brutally assaulted and was lucky to survive when the bullet brushed past his head.

Vendor assaulted, robbed for selling cheap onions
August 2013:

New Delhi: A vegetable vendor was brutally assaulted and robbed by a group of rival vendors, as the former was selling onions and potatoes at a lower price than the wholesale market.

Murdered for not paying Rs 180 food bill
April 2013:

NEW Delhi: A man, who dined at a south Delhi restaurant and was unable to pay the Rs 180 bill, was beaten to death by the infuriated restaurant owner.

Labourer killed over undercooked chicken
Feb 2013:

Gurgaon: Two labourers got into a heated argument over a piece of chicken that was served to them at a party. One of the labourers picked up a brick and struck the other on the head, killing him instantly.

Man shot dead for spilling chicken tikka
Dec 2010:

New Delhi: A software engineer was shot dead by a history-sheeter after the former accidentally spilled a plate of chicken tikka that the accused was carrying. The victim had opened the door of his car and accidentally struck the accused.

Sign up for all the latest news, top galleries and trending videos from

loading image
This website uses cookie or similar technologies, to enhance your browsing experience and provide personalised recommendations. By continuing to use our website, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy. OK