2,850 watches to mark 150 years of HC?

Many lawyers feel spending Rs 27 lakh on the items ufffd as part of the High Court's sesquicentennial celebrations ufffd would be a waste, and if the purchase is made, a proper tender process should be followed

2,850 watches to mark 150 years of HC?

The mood is celebratory at Bombay High Court these days — after all the institution recently completed 150 years of glorious legal heritage. So, subsequent to a decision to purchase cars worth Rs 65 lakh for judges from the special funds allotted for the commemoration, the HC administration proposed to procure 2,850 wristwatches, costing approximately Rs 27 lakh. And then it all came to a grinding halt, as the government machinery refused to budge.

Glorious existence: The sesquicentennial celebrations of the Bombay High Court took place in August this year. File pic

Sources say, the HC administration is still trying to get approval for the acquisition of the Titan watches — a decision which was taken in the last week of September. But, the plan is currently wedged in procedural clearances. While state government officials are tight-lipped, S B Shukre, registrar general of the High Court, said, “We intend to finalise the issue (of procurement of wristwatches) by Monday. I will be unable to comment on the matter till then.”

However, sources aware of the developments said such a decision needs prior approval by the state government as the orders (issued on August 14, 2012) about making finances — a maximum of Rs 2 crore — available for the sesquicentennial celebrations do not specify any purchase of wristwatches.

Besides, any procurement that incurs expenditure above Rs 50,000 needs a tendering process, which the HC administration seems to have overlooked, say sources, quoting a Government Resolution (GR) issued in July 1993. A government official, requesting anonymity, said how and why a particular brand of wristwatches has been selected is not known.

He said even if the watches were available at a special discounted price, other companies too could have made such offers. He also said wristwatches cannot be deemed a part of the celebrations.

Interestingly, details of tenders — for everything from printing Diwali cards to outsourcing photocopy work — are regularly uploaded on the High Court website.

Also worth noting is the fact that the concluding ceremony of the yearlong sesquicentennial celebrations was held on August 18, which was attended by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. u00a0

Lawyers speak
If this is true, it is unfortunate that public money is being spent in such a self-serving and frivolous manner. After all, the money was allotted for a specific purpose — the sesquicentennial celebrations.
— Advocate Prosper D’Souza

It is hard to believe that no tender system was adopted. I wonder whom they are going to give so many watches to. It would be acceptable if they sold the watches to the general public, as they have done with the commemorative booku00a0

— u00a0Advocate Ahmad Abdi

u00a0

In regards to the allotment u00a0of funds without tenders, transparency is the hallmark of any administration. As they say, justice must be seen to be done, and it must also be believed to be done. Given that the court is such an important institution, it should ensure that it meets these requirements

— Advocate Mohan Pillai

u00a0

Such decisions are taken by a collegium, usually comprising judges. Then the proposal goes to the government and the law and justice ministry. A tender process is not always necessary.u00a0

— Advocate Ishwariprasad Bagaria

"Exciting news! Mid-day is now on WhatsApp Channels