Well done India, but don't bury fixing probe

Jun 16, 2013, 17:16 IST | Ian Chappell

History suggests the investigation into IPL scandal is most likely to be swept away on a tidal wave of euphoria

Thanks to some commanding performances, India has firmly entrenched itself as a favourite to win the concluding Champions Trophy.

While the seam bowling has been a pleasant surprise, it’s India’s powerful batting line-up that has elevated it to favouritism and the envy of every other nation. That India could regenerate so quickly and successfully, a batting line-up that was in danger of being decimated by the regular loss of top-class players, is a tribute to their production line.

Where India is currently embarrassed by run-scoring riches other strong nations, particularly Australia and possibly South Africa down the track, are in danger of being reduced to the classification of batting poor. India’s remarkable regeneration act has also succeeded in invalidating Australian excuses for it’s current batting woes. Those arguments range from the sudden departure of senior players to being the result of playing too much T 20 cricket.

The latter reason is exposed as dubious because India is the home of the IPL, the richest and most concentrated T 20 competition in the cricket world.

But therein lies a potential conflict if India does experience the elation of winning the Champions Trophy. Will the tide of euphoria in the country sweep aside the IPL corruption scandal or will it mean the rampant fixing problems are attacked with renewed vigour?

Before coming to a conclusion, it’s instructive to examine the incongruities currently in play regarding discipline in cricket.

There’s been a spate of strong punishment meted out to players who have transgressed either on or off the field. These include New Zealand’s Jesse Ryder and Australia’s David Warner being suspended for drink related incidents and West Indies wicket-keeper Dinesh Ramdin for poor sportsmanship on the field.

I have no problem with strong punishment being administered to players who exhibit questionable judgement; on the contrary it’s crucial if these problems are to be reduced.

However, I do take issue with the inequities in the approach to disciplining offending players and administrators. If the administrators [who generally hand out the punishment] were subjected to the same standards as players when it comes to poor judgement and mis-behaviour, then maybe some of the off-field incompetence could be eradicated.

In addition to multiple misjudgments, many administrators seem to totally disregard conflict of interest as a concept. And via the IPL scandal, it’s also obvious that corruption is an issue among officials.

While the IPL was a visionary concept, it’s original implementation was flawed.

The blueprint for the IPL could easily have been lifted from a best-selling novel with a central theme of corruption. It was a script combining immense sums of money, the glitz of Bollywood, after-match parties involving players and the on-field performance being diminished by upgrading the importance of off-field activities. This subjected T 20 cricket to the danger of becoming entertainment in the realm of professional wrestling, rather than sport.

The fact that no one challenged this concept is symptomatic of the myopic vision in cricket administration worldwide.

Their failure to apply a zero tolerance and draconian punishment regime when fixing first raised it’s ugly head was a major misjudgment. And with the rest of the cricket world standing by and allowing India to rule with dictatorial zeal, it makes the other countries accomplices in the chaos.

Both players and officials need to reacquaint themselves with the notion of the game’s integrity.

It’s unreasonable to expect players to behave impeccably whilst they’re being exposed to some officials acting corruptly at worst and with a lack of commonsense at best. When players are surrounded by administrators whose sole priority appears to be “a strong bottom line”, it‘s a bit rich to then accuse cricketers of being “self-centred”.

Past history suggests the investigation into the IPL corruption scandal is most likely to be swept away on a tidal wave of euphoria if India wins the Champions Trophy. By reversing that trend the officials would be displaying the courage and foresight the game has been so lacking. It would also be a much-needed boost for the integrity of the game. 

Go to top