Vanita Kohli-Khandekar Column: Changing the male stereotype

It was day one of the National Film Development Corporationrsquos Film Bazaar in Goa last week I was listening to the conversations around me In the session just before mine film critic Namrata Joshi was chatting with filmmakers Sudhir Mishra and Anurag Basu and producer Vani Tripathi Tikoo about female protagonists in Bollywood today The question they were trying to answer was ldquohow real is the discourserdquo The discussion centered around familiar lines mdash how regressive the female stereotype in film and TV is how some films and shows do try to change that and so onIn films or TV shows it is rare to see men being truly liberal or able to cope with women who have a mind of their own The one instance that I remember is when Ajay Devgnrsquos character in Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam 1999 realises that the woman he has just married is in love with someone else and he decides to find her lover and unite themIt was a wellintentioned but very lsquopeople like usrsquo discussion The fact is people in that room including me represent the top sliver of the Indian population mdash the ones who have got a decent education come from families that did not repress the girl child and so onThe fact is also that films TV shows advertising have done a huge amount to change the stereotypes around women It was advertising that began showing the girl child instead of a boy child in the late eighties early nineties It is advertising which moved beyond the saree and kitchen before films followed with the imagery of a woman as a working entity too It is now very normal for women irrespective of class or town to want to break through their little prisons and do more That is how you hear of taxi drivers golf players and pilots coming out of smalltowns and poor homes in IndiaThe Kserials that everyone derided were not meant for people like you and me but for families where domestic strife is a reality I remember arguing with editors that just because soap operas dramatised a reality we were not familiar with they werenrsquot regressive Thankfully a 2008 study by Robert Jensen of Brown University and Emily Oster of the University of Chicago proved my point It showed to quote from the abstract to the paper that ldquoThe introduction of cable television in rural India is associated with significant decreases in the reported acceptability of domestic violence towards women and son preference as well as increases in womenrsquos autonomy and decreases in fertility We also find suggestive evidence that exposure to cable increases school enrolment for younger children perhaps through increased participation of women in household decisionmakingrdquoLargely then mainstream media has done a very good job of bringing women to the forefront of debates and empowering themWhat it has not done well enough is changing male stereotypes by giving them roles images and contexts that are emancipated What is the point of having independent women with a mind of their own when half the humanity around them is unable to cope with that Advertising does a fair amount of envelopepushing on male stereotypes through its tender loving type of protagonist But in films or TV shows it is rare to see men being truly liberal or able to cope with women who have a mind of their own The one instance that I remember is when Ajay Devgnrsquos character in Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam 1999 realises that the woman he has just married is in love with someone else and he decides to find her lover and unite them To his Dadrsquos incredulous questioning of this he says that ldquoManhood Mardangi is not about forcing her to be my wife it is about having the courage to let her go to whoever she wants to be withrdquo That to my mind was a really envelopepushing statement though the filmrsquos ending was clicheacutedBy showing men who cry cook or take on the housework at the end of an equally tiring day for both partners we push the envelope Sometimes in real life it doesnrsquot work quite so simply For instance if a man takes his kids to school or takes time off from work to bring up a kid there is a social awkwardness about it Much of it also depends on the women mdash how they bring up their sons If we treat them like little princelings at home they will grow up thinking that they can put their feet up and relax And if we bring them up in a home where both parents carry the load equally there is respect for the other gender they will grow up believing that women and men are equal human beingsWe need to change before the imagery changes But we will change on a large scale only when the imagery does Chicken and eggish thatThe writer is a media specialist and author Follow her on Twitter at httptwittercomvanitakohlik