The commissioner who left Bombay bankrupt. Nearly

The man behind one of South Mumbais most frequented and well stocked markets is also the guy responsible for giving Bombay its electric streetlights They were called Crawfords Fireflies after Arthur Teavers Crawford the citys first Municipal Commissioner The lights installed at Esplanade Churchgate Bhendi Bazaar and the surrounding areas led to a drop in crimes much to the relief of residentsThe mans legacy however is a checkered one leaving you with the same feeling that you experience after stepping out of the chaotic market named after him on an even more chaotic street In his zeal to improve conditions in the city Crawford indulged in irreversible financial mismanagement that continued even during his time as commissioner of the southern division of the Bombay Presidency He was charged on numerous counts from corruption to borrowing money from local subordinates but he managed to skip severe punishmentOregonbased scholar Dr Michael Metelits traces the mans questionable intentions in the justreleased title The Arthur Crawford Scandal Corruption Governance and Indian Victims Oxford University Press The Indian subcontinent was under the direct rule of The Crown In 1862 Sir Bartle Frere became the first Governor of Bombay under this new rulebook Seeing the unplanned development of this fastgrowing commercial centre of the Empire the farsighted administrator decided to break down the walls of the Fort to facilitate decongestion and open up the city Public utility services like broad roads sanitation and drainage were on top on his list Enter the shrewd town planner Crawford who aligned with Freres vision Frere was keen to build a wholesale market and arranged for a design competition William Emersons plan that married Moorish architecture and vernacular influences bagged the first prize the building was erected in 1868 and the market opened for business in 1871 With Freres blessings Crawford whose term extended from 1865 to 1871 took his role too seriously in trying to clean up the system he had inherited leaving Bombay on the cusp of bankruptcyWilliam Emerson won the design competition for the market because it was believed to be most feasible for the citys climate The corner site was picked to ensure accessibility to the Black Indian and White British Towns of the original island city as well as its proximity to the CST terminus formerly Victoria TerminusDr Metelits first learnt of Crawfords corrupt legacy in 1970 while researching his doctoral dissertation at the Maharashtra State Archives in Kala Ghoda I found a pamphlet published by the Pune Sarvajanik Sabha about a public meeting in Pune that wanted to urge the Viceroy to retain the promise by the Bombay government to protect mamlatdar senior official of a taluka witnesses of immunity from prosecution or career harm if they would testify truthfully about payments to Crawford I was struck by the rationale of speeches by Tilak and Gokhale Although the subject of that meeting wasnt linked with his dissertation the account stayed with Dr MetelitsDecades later shortly after retiring from government service I read a book about the British who staffed the Indian Civil Service It was a panegyric pure and simple In the book Crawford was termed a black sheep among the otherwise selfsacrificing men who spent most of their adult life away from home I felt the remark as little more than a weak slap on the wrist about someone who ruined lives So when I returned to Mumbai a decade later I decided to research the Crawford scandal in detailThe result was the book Edited excerpts from the interviewWhy was Crawfords term as Bombay Municipal Commissioner taintedCrawford borrowed heavily and often rewarded friends and persons to whom he was indebted with contracts to carry out municipal works such that it nearly ran the city bankrupt Secondly when he was called to book for the financial situation he feigned poor health and fled to England Once out of India the law couldnt extradite him He repeated this act later when his corruption was exposed in PuneDid his civic projects see the light of dayNearly all of them saw completion They were necessary and fundamentally well done Its no accident that the central market in the city was named after him He introduced electric lights The cost of each project and the number of projects are what ran the city coffers nearly dryHow did he manage to outsmart the lawI was keen to shed light on the Indian victims of the scandal However it became apparent that their harassment required me to also document it Crawford got away without any career or financial penalty and then again as commissioner of the southern division Furthermore he constantly reshaped and developed his system of extortion in each station He may have also assumed that British officials would never convict him based on the testimonies of Indian witnesses Its this last point that is disturbing and is the reason why my book examines the Hanmantrao trial centred on Crawfords chief agent who was tried and found guilty while Crawford was declared innocent in detail but not the records of The Crawford Commission enquiry set up by the British government using English laws It was a questionable one with biased interpretations according to the author The latter was a disgrace to the British notion of justiceHow critical was it to document the role of mamlatdarsI have great respect for the mamlatdars The difficult part was to get them to testify under oath about accepting money for career favours It is only when they promised witnesses immunity from prosecution and career damage that some testified They were the lowhanging fruit easy to harvest and full of relevant information As educated persons they had imbibed moral values that the Raj proudly espoused when it was convenient to do soThen how did Crawford continue to remain popularInscription of Arthur Crawfordrsquos name on a friezeHe was popular in Bombay He had many friends and after the financial embarrassment passed his reputation reflected the many improvements like sanitation and connecting various parts of the city In fact when the Presidency government wanted to try him before a special commission Crawford insisted that they meet in Bombay where he had influential friends When the government insisted that the commission convene in Pune he requested for judges from outside the PresidencyCatch up on all the latest Mumbai news crime news current affairs and also a complete guide on Mumbai from food to things to do and events across the city here Also download the new midday Android and iOS apps to get latest updates