Home / Mumbai / Mumbai News / Article / Bombay High Court quashes CIDCO’s Rs 24.58 lakh transfer charge against Nerul housing society

Bombay High Court quashes CIDCO’s Rs 24.58 lakh transfer charge against Nerul housing society

Two housing societies refused to pay, fought for a decade, and got the Bombay HC to quash a R24.58 lakh demand. Relief is narrow, but thousands of societies with pre-1990 leases now have a roadmap

  • WhatsAppBookmarkBookmark
Listen to this article :
Surya Co-operative Housing Society in Vashi. File pic/By Special Arrangement

Surya Co-operative Housing Society in Vashi. File pic/By Special Arrangement

The Bombay High Court has quashed CIDCO’s Rs 24.58 lakh transfer-charge demand against Manmandir Co-operative Housing Society in Nerul and similar demands concerning Surya Co-operative Housing Society in Vashi, ruling that a 1990 regulatory amendment cannot be applied retrospectively to their earlier lease agreements. However, the relief is limited to the two societies. The Navi Mumbai Housing Federation’s bid for a wider declaration covering 2528 societies failed because the court was not provided with the necessary lease documents and particulars. The dispute dates to October 26, 2016, when CIDCO asked Manmandir Society to pay Rs 24.58 lakh for transfers involving 27 flats. The society challenged the demand, arguing that its lease did not impose such a liability on individual members. The federation and the societies approached the High Court in 2018. mid-day reported their challenge to CIDCO’s transfer premium on March 16, 2023, in a story titled “CIDCO levying transfer premium is wrong”.

What court held

The bench of Justices Bharati Dangre and Manjusha Deshpande held that Explanation (iii) to Regulation 3(vii) of the New Bombay Disposal of Lands Regulations, 1975, inserted on February 8, 1990, could not be applied to the two societies’ pre-amendment leases, which did not contain the relevant obligation. The court set aside CIDCO’s demand against Manmandir and corresponding transfer-charge demands concerning Surya Society. It did not strike down the regulation or grant a blanket exemption to other societies. The court also declined wider relief sought by federation because it had not produced necessary documents. Thirteen societies listed in petition were excluded from the relief because the exhibits contained only their names. CIDCO argued that the charges helped it recover unearned gains when flats on land allotted at concessional rates were resold, and that the leases were subject to applicable regulations. Court, however, held that the amendment could not impose a new contractual liability retrospectively on two societies.

Read Next Story
World Mental Health Day: IITians discuss campus stress and demands for stronger support systems›

Trending Stories

Latest Photoscta-pos

Latest VideosView All

Latest Web StoriesView All

Mid-Day FastView All