Home / News / India News / Article /
Right to say I don't
Updated On: 11 March, 2010 07:28 AM IST | | Sanjeev Devasia and Amit Kumar
A new trend has emerged as estranged couples peep into each other's I-T records to protect themselves from dowry harassment. And the weapon of choice is Right To Information Act
A new trend has emerged as estranged couples peep into each other's I-T records to protect themselves from dowry harassment. And the weapon of choice is Right To Information Act
Case I: Ritika Sharma and her father claimed in a police complaint that they had provided Rs 30 lakh in dowry
(jewellery, cash and kind) to Ritika's husband Mohan Sharma. Facing the prospect of imprisonment, Mohan Sharma filed an RTI application, seeking the Income Tax details of his father-in-law. It was revealed that Ritika's father had only displayed a nominal income. It then became apparent that the claims made by the father-daughter duo about the dowry payment were false. The matter is sub-judice. (names changed)
Case II: A month ago, Visakha Malhotra filed an RTI application seeking details of her ex-husband's income after she was denied rightful maintenance following her divorce. Her husband had claimed that he was a businessman. "Her petition was based on her right to live with dignity," said a senior I-T official, on condition of anonymity. (name changed)
According to Income Tax officials, the trend of seeking RTI for dowry and maintenance cases began after a Delhi High Court judgement (WP (C) 3114/2007). In a 2007 case, Bhagat Singh was denied information regarding the earnings of his wife, with whom he had a discord, by the Income-Tax department on the ground that the matter was being investigated.
u00a0
Singh, who was accused by his wife Saroj Nimal of accepting a dowry of Rs 10 lakh from her, filed a request with the I-T department for investigating into his wife's sources of income in view of the fact that she was a primary school teacher. In a landmark judgement, the court directed the I-T department to provide the information sought by Bhagat Singh.
Since then, the trend has caught on. "There are around 30 ranges in the NCR and each of these ranges process or receive around three to four RTI applications seeking I-T details and most of them are related to either dowry harassment or maintenance cases. No other RTI information is entertained by the Income Tax department except those which have public interest information of importance. Under the I-T Act 1961, disclosure of information respecting assesses is provided for in public interest," said an I-T official.u00a0


