shot-button
E-paper E-paper
Home > Mumbai > Mumbai News > Article > Mumbai A year after horrific Nana Chowk accident 73 year old Dina Desai seeks reflection and action

Mumbai: A year after horrific Nana Chowk accident, 73-year-old Dina Desai seeks reflection and action

Updated on: 05 December,2025 07:49 AM IST  |  Mumbai
Hemal Ashar | hemal@mid-day.com

SoBo resident marks one year of injury after falling through a broken gutter lid; people flood her with images of broken infra across city

Mumbai: A year after horrific Nana Chowk accident, 73-year-old Dina Desai seeks reflection and action

Near the Mahalaxmi racecourse (right) on the ground near Kemps Corner. PIC BY SPECIAL ARRANGEMENT

Listen to this article
Mumbai: A year after horrific Nana Chowk accident, 73-year-old Dina Desai seeks reflection and action
x
00:00

Yesterday, Thursday, December 4, Malabar Hill resident Dina Desai marked a sombre first anniversary. This one did not warrant celebrations but introspection and action. Desai, 73, suffered a heinous injury one year ago at Nana Chowk when she had gone to buy medicines from a pharmacy.

She had placed her leg on what she took to be a grated gutter after her car dropped her close to the pharmacy. The diminutive Desai’s left leg went all the way up to her thigh into the gutter grate as two spokes of this grate broke.


Dina Desai marks the injury anniversary. Pics/By Special ArrangementDina Desai marks the injury anniversary. Pics/By Special Arrangement



Desai’s cries for help were heeded, and then, battling excruciating pain, she was diagnosed with a large Haematoma. A Haematoma or blood suffusion is localised bleeding outside of the blood vessels, due to either disease or trauma, including injury or surgery. Some Haematomas can be seen as surface bruises.

The suffering

Dina Desai a year ago, with her injured legDina Desai a year ago, with her injured leg

One year on, Desai said, “I still battle with pain. As a swimmer and walker, I was fairly agile, but this has affected my agility. Since it was my left leg that was affected, I have been using my right leg and putting all my weight on it, so it hurts too. Most of all, the sound of the grate spokes caving in as I stepped on it has stayed with me.”

This cycle may serve as warning. Pics/By Special Arrangement
This cycle may serve as warning. Pics/By Special Arrangement

At that time, Desai had followed through to ensure that there was some action taken, and the gutter grate was repaired by the BMC. Personnel had stated that this was not a broken gutter but a ‘double water entrance’. That, though, is a mere technicality. The point is that the infrastructure broke, and a senior citizen suffered as a result.

Action caution

Slip and break a hip in Colaba?
Slip and break a hip in Colaba?

Desai has turned agony into action. A couple of weeks ago, to ‘mark’ this date, Desai asked people to send her pictures of broken grates or gutter covers. She said, “The pictures started flowing in. I saw broken infrastructure outside the Mahalaxmi racecourse a few weeks ago when I had visited for an art show and was walking back to my car. Many of these photos are taken in upscale SoBo. I want to warn people, I have done so earlier, not to step on this infrastructure. Always look down while walking. Some of these broken covers look strong, but that is deceptive. If spokes could give way under my 50-kg weight, it is entirely possible that these covers may break entirely if somebody heavy steps on them. You will be in severe pain even if just your leg slips in, as I experienced.”

Keep your eyes on the ground near Kemps CornerKeep your eyes on the ground near Kemps Corner

Many photos supplied by Desai have been taken by persons who learnt of her initiative. She explained, “This is to create awareness. I hope authorities become proactive, find out about these problems themselves and start repairs. I am also grateful to alert and intrepid citizens who have responded once I announced my initiative on social media, roughly three weeks ago. Yet the sheer numbers and Formula-I speed at which pictures are coming in shows this is a widespread issue. The one-year anniversary is no memorable milestone, just an awakening,” Desai concluded.

"Exciting news! Mid-day is now on WhatsApp Channels Subscribe today by clicking the link and stay updated with the latest news!" Click here!

Did you find this article helpful?

Yes
No

Help us improve further by providing more detailed feedback and stand a chance to win a 3-month e-paper subscription! Click Here

Note: Winners will be selected via a lucky draw.

Help us improve further by providing more detailed feedback and stand a chance to win a 3-month e-paper subscription! Click Here

Note: Winners will be selected via a lucky draw.

malabar hill brihanmumbai municipal corporation Mumbai roads mumbai news mumbai

Mid-Day Web Stories

Mid-Day Web Stories

This website uses cookie or similar technologies, to enhance your browsing experience and provide personalised recommendations. By continuing to use our website, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy. OK