Indian government should hang its head in shame: BBC filmmaker

Washington: British-based filmmaker Leslee Udwin says the Indian government should hang its head in shame for banning her documentary on the December 16, 2012 fatal gang-rape of a 23-year-old Delhi woman.

India banned the BBC documentary - "India's Daughter" - on the rape of the woman who has come to be known as Nirbhaya or the Fearless, following an uproar over convicted rapist Mukesh Singh's comments blaming the victim.

"The home minister blamed the protesters when these were protests on the Gandhian level, peaceful and right and good," Udwin told the Los Angeles Times. "The irony is it only became violent when the police got involved."

"The government should hang its head in shame" for the ban, she was quoted as saying in an interview on Monday before the US premiere of her film at event in downtown Manhattan ahead of an airing on PBS later this year.

British filmmaker Leslee Udwin. Pic/ PTI

Udwin, has also denied accusations in the Indian media that Mukesh Singh was either paid for his time or interviewed without his consent. A title card at the start of the film refutes the latter claim.

Actresses Meryl Streep, Freida Pinto, Dakota Fanning and singer Chris Martin were among those at the premiere, an event organized by women's-rights groups Vital Voices and Plan International at Manhattan's Baruch College.

The celebrities became involved because of the initial interest of Alan Rickman, who is a friend of Udwin's and began spreading the word among other entertainers, the Times said.

Streep led a candle-lighting ceremony before the screening, reading some of the victim's accounts of the assault, then issued a plea to the audience.

"We're called here to contend with something more than rape," Streep was quoted as saying. "What is worse than violence? Violence sanctioned by misogyny."

Pinto, a producer on the movie, told the Times in an interview before the screening that she saw this as "a universal story, and something I got involved with because it's not just about what happens in India".

She gave an address after the screening in which she criticised even Western attitudes about the Indian gang-rape, noting a TV script she had been sent recently that contained a joke about it.

She also issued a wide-ranging plea to people as diverse policymakers and teenage boys to shift their thinking.

She closed her speech by asking people to close their eyes and be "bathed in the light, the light that was Jyoti."

Udwin also took the stage after the screening as part of a panel discussion about women's rights issues.

"The disease is not rape, and the disease is not human trafficking," she was quoted as saying. "The disease is gender inequality. And all these things are the metastases of the primary tumour."



  • Dori20-Mar-2015

    A lot of times (Most), people need to learn to stay away from other people's personal issues. Especially, if it is not in their own countries. Deal with your own in your own country, not the others. With things like this, they have to add something to make a true story become a hollywood material of fantasy because they do not have all the information. Sure, you are the good people, and we are the terrorist as always portrait in your films. It is pure reality. No shame, that is all there is.

  • SP12-Mar-2015

    Udwin It's hypocrisy. Certain things needs to remain silent. The pain is huge. You will be busy making films after this one and will forget and start enjoying life and unfortunately some one will give you award for making this film. Both I consider are criminals of society. Think about Nirbhaya's family who may be trying to come to terms but you have hurt them again beyond repairs much more than incidence. Since there is verbal insult to the Girl you should be sued by her family.

  • Dr.V.N.Sharma11-Mar-2015

    I agree with Udwin that "The disease is gender inequality. And all these things are the metastases of the primary tumour."But it also has a sense of exhibiting male superiority anywhere, any time. I feel one has to go through the trauma and agony the girl Jyoti (or call her Nirbhaya) had to go through on that fateful evening of 16th Dec 2012. And in stead of taking stern and fast action to take the culprits to the gallows Govt is trying to take away freedom of free communication of views.

Leave a Reply