Mumbai: Locals concerned about cell towers atop seven-storey Bandra building
Alarm bells peal at charming St Roque nook, as residents hare about in vain for answers about cell towers in one of area's tallest buildings
The cell towers atop Bhagtani Apartments building. Pics/Dutta Kumbhar
A radiating controversy over cell towers atop a seven-storey building has gripped a sleepy Bandra West alcove. For a year now, the locals have been asking residents of one of the area's tallest buildings, called Bhagtani Apartments, about whether they have adequate permissions to have the towers, which are known to emit harmful radiation.
In March last year, the locals of the well-heeled nook, represented by the St Roque Road Advance Locality Management (ALM), were alarmed upon noticing the cluster of towers, because they had read and heard enough, they stated, about the possible "harmful health effects of radiation from mobile tower antennae".
Freddie Vaz, Rita D'Lima, Patrice Fernandes and Deepika D'Souza
"Ever since the towers came up in March 2017, we have been asking Bhagtani apartments whether they have obtained permissions for the towers. We have got no replies," say residents Deepika D'Souza and Freddie Vaz pointing to the towers atop the building. Correspondence to the building began as early as April 2017. An extract from a letter to the secretary, Bhagtani Apartments dated April 8 warns, "Electromagnetic radiation as well as radio frequencies adversely affect the health of any living organism that comes in contact with these waves…" The area is dominated by buildings of three to four storeys and cottages that take you back to another era.
Residents said, "We have over a 100 plots in this area. Many residential buildings here are more than 50 years old. Some of these cottages are at least 90 years old." The cell towers are a worry, residents said, "because Bhagtani Apartments, at seven storeys, is [one of] the tallest building in the area and overlooks most other buildings, so the radiation will affect all."
While letters to Bhagtani Apartments evinced no reply, residents have sent letters to the H-ward officer to ascertain whether permissions have been got for the same. An excerpt from one letter, dated July 7, 2017, from the Mumbai Fire Brigade signed by Station Officer P A Sawant (Divisional Fire Officer) refers to Bhagtani Apartments says: "There are mobile towers installed over the lift shaft and on the building terrace. When asked, the party has not produced permissions for erecting the mobile towers on the terrace and the sanctioned plan of the building."
It goes on to say that the assistant municipal commissioner of H/W ward is requested to depute an engineer concerned to "visit the premises and verify necessary permissions for erecting of mobile tower and inspect and take appropriate action against the mobile tower over the lift tower accordingly." Residents stated that this letter came after they cited concerns about one mobile tower located over the lift shaft being a fire hazard, putting other buildings, too, in the area at risk.
Numerous efforts by this reporter to contact Bhagtani Apartments representatives were unfruitful, with a couple of residents saying that those authorised to speak were out of the country. Rita D'Lima, a resident of the area, said, "We are being bounced off like ping pong balls between different agencies, from the ward officer, the fire authorities and the building itself." Patrice Fernandes said strongly, "We want answers instead of the constant back and forth, where we are being strung along by all concerned."
When told that the ill-effects of mobile tower radiation was still a contested topic they said, "First, we want to know if the towers are legal and if the building has permission to install them. Secondly, should we wait for somebody here to fall seriously ill for 'proof' of health hazards and then ask for action?" asks the quartet, voicing the sentiment of several residents.
Legal or illegal?
Assistant municipal commis-sioner H-ward Sharad Ughade said, "Mobile towers erected before 2013 have a stay in court. Others need the permission of the building proposal special cell department. Action against unauthorized mobile towers will be taken by the ward building factory department." The ward building factory department personnel said on condition of anonymity that they had visited Bhagtani Apartments to check claims about the towers, but were unable to access the terrace as it was locked whenever they visited.
Silence not golden
Suyog Telematics, a communications infrastructure provider, has installed the towers on Bhagtani Apartments. Tushar Shah, business development head and spokesperson, confirmed the same, but despite numerous attempts, did not revert to phone calls, emails or messages to comment on the controversy over whether all permissions were in place for the towers.
Catch up on all the latest Mumbai news, crime news, current affairs, and also a complete guide on Mumbai from food to things to do and events across the city here. Also download the new mid-day Android and iOS apps to get latest updates
Sign up for all the latest news, top galleries and trending videos from Mid-day.comSubscribe