BNPL vs credit cards.
Two popular short-term financing options are available to consumers in India. One offers instant short-term financing with minimal documentation, while the other offers a revolving line of credit with rewards, stronger consumer protection, and flexibility. Have you guessed it? These options are Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) and Credit Cards, respectively. Although both let you buy now and pay later, they differ in terms and approval. Let's look at these options in detail and why a credit card is still a better choice for everyday spending.
BNPL is a short-term financial option offered by fintech companies or bank partners that lets you buy now and pay later, often in instalments. It is an instant option, requires minimal documentation, and doesn't require a hard credit check.
A credit card online is issued by a bank or financial institution with a pre-approved revolving credit limit. Once approved, cardholders need to activate credit card services before using the limit to buy something online or offline where the card is accepted. Each month, you receive a bill for your purchases and can pay it in full or carry the balance forward. Credit card issuers may offer rewards, cashback, or discounts on card usage.
Cost Comparison: Interest, Fees and Charges
When it comes to costs, the main difference is how each option charges you for late payments. Here is a detailed breakdown of how interest, fees, and charges stack up between the two:
|
Charge Category |
Credit Cards |
Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) |
|
Normal Interest (APR) |
24% to 49% per annum. Only charged if you carry a balance past the grace period. |
0% for short-term (pay-in-3 or 15–30 day) cycles. Longer tenures carry 15% to 30% interest. |
|
Late Payment Fees |
Progressive structure based on your balance. Typically ranges from Rs 100 to Rs 1,300 per cycle. |
Flat fee applied immediately. Typically Rs 200 to Rs 500 per missed instalment. |
|
Joining / Annual Fee |
Rs 500 to Rs 3,000+ depending on the card tier. Often waived if annual spend milestones are met. |
Typically, Rs 0. Free to activate, download, and hold the account |
Rewards, Cashback and Lifestyle Benefits
Primary rewards: When it comes to rewards, credit cards outclass BNPL across every category. Credit cards offer spending-based luxury benefits, while BNPL is a financing option designed for quick, convenient checkout.
Cashback: Credit cards often offer uncapped or high-ceiling cashback. BNPL offers cashback, but they are strictly capped.
Lifestyle benefits: Credit cards offer airport lounge access, surcharge waivers, movie & dining perks, and insurance. BNPL doesn't offer such benefits.
You get the best credit card offers, travel benefits, cashback, based on the selected card.
Impact on Credit Score and Credit History
Credit cards and BNPL affect your credit score very differently. A credit card is a long-term financing option designed to build your credit history, while BNPL, a hybrid financing option, comes with a little upside and carries high downside risk when it comes to credit scores.
|
Factor |
Credit Cards |
Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) |
|
Credit Check Type |
Hard Inquiry |
Soft or Hard Inquiry |
|
Loan Classification |
Reported as a Revolving Credit Card Account. |
Reported as a Personal Loan / Consumer Durable Loan. |
|
Positive Score Impact |
High. |
Very Low. |
|
Negative Score Impact |
High. |
Severe. |
|
Credit Utilisation Ratio |
Highly Impactful. |
Not Applicable. |
Before you apply for any product, check credit score to ensure approval.
When you use a credit card, you use the bank's money, giving you strong protection like zero fraud liability, chargeback rights, regulatory oversight, and insurance. For example, if you bought something online and got a fake product or nothing at all, you can initiate a formal chargeback.
Conclusion
For someone who wants higher rewards and long-term security, credit cards are a good choice. Credit cards provide rewards ecosystems (with reward points, cashback, and discounts), milestone benefits, and other perks like surcharge waivers, movie and dining perks, complimentary airport lounge access, etc. Additionally, credit cards can help with your financial future by building a strong, positive credit history. They provide unmatched protection on high-value purchases like buying electronics or booking international travel with robust regulatory safeguards, including global chargeback rights and zero fraud liability.
You can use BNPL as a temporary, short-term budgeting tool for everyday apps (like food or grocery delivery) where you want a 1-click checkout. Use a Credit Card for all primary spending, recurring bills, and security coverage, and pay the statement balance in full every single month. If you want to apply for a card, check the documents required for credit card, compare features, and choose the one which matches your spending habits.
References:
https://www.bajajfinserv.in/difference-between-bnpl-vs-credit-card
Disclaimer: The information provided on the Website does not constitute investment advice, financial advice, trading advice, or any other form of advice, and you should not interpret any of the financial content as such. Please conduct your own due diligence and consult with a financial advisor before making any investment decisions. Midday does not endorse or promote any such activities, and you access them at your own risk, fully understanding the monetary and legal consequences involved. Midday shall not be held responsible for any losses you may incur as a result of using any such apps or websites.