Subscription Subscription
Home > Mumbai > Mumbai News > Article > Esther Anuhya verdict Sanap has lost the right to live in society

Esther Anuhya verdict: 'Sanap has lost the right to live in society'

Updated on: 29 October,2015 08:40 AM IST  | 
Sailee Dhayalkar |

Special Public Prosecutor Raja Thakre sought the death penalty for techie Esther Anuhya rapist and murderer Chandrabhan Sanap; the quantum of punishment will be announced on Friday

Esther Anuhya verdict: 'Sanap has lost the right to live in society'

On Wednesday, the prosecution sought the death penalty for Chandrabhan Sanap after he had been convicted by a special women’s court on Tuesday for raping and murdering Esther Anuhya.

Also read: Esther Anuhya murder - How cops had caught Sanap with help of CCTV clips

Esther Anuhya and Chandrabhan Sanap
Esther Anuhya and Chandrabhan Sanap

The prosecution said that he does not deserve any sympathy or to have any mercy shown to him. Special Public Prosecutor Raja Thakare began with the arguments for sentencing by demanding the death sentence for Sanap.

Also read: Esther Anuhya case - 'The motive was to satisfy unbridled lust'

He began by saying, “In the present case, there are two offences of which the accused has been found guilty which attract the death penalty, namely the offences under sections 302 (murder) and 376A (while committing rape, inflicting an injury that causes a woman’s death) of the Indian Penal Code. It is very relevant to note that section 376A has come on the statue book as late as 2013 and that too specifically after the Nirbhaya case.”

Also read: Esther Anuhya case: Sanap convicted for rape, murder of techie

Crimes against women
Thakare spoke on what Esther’s family might have gone through. He said, “Esther was a working woman expecting to get engaged, an engineer by profession, who had left her parental abode and was travelling alone. There are no words to console her family. On January 5 (2014), she arrived in Mumbai and went missing…until her body was found.”

Also read: Esther Anuhya's father expects death penalty for Sanap

Citing the mitigating circumstances, Thakare said, “The accused may say he has a wife and an old mother to be looked after, but the accused himself has not cared about the impact of his ghastly act on the family of the deceased, who was a well-educated engineer and a working woman. Consequently, the accused cannot plead this as a ground for leniency.”

Thakare also said that each of the mitigating circumstances like Sanap’s age — early 30s — his now-cured tuberculosis infection, the fact that he has old parents, a wife and two young children and no complaints from jail authorities, should not let him escape the maximum punishment.

Sanap’s three marriages, Thakare argued, showed that he was a womaniser. “He committed rape to satisfy his lust… he has lost the right to live in society,” he said. At the end, Thakare said, for all these reasons, the accused does not deserve any sympathy or to have any mercy shown to him.

Also read: 'Recovered clothes belong to my granddaughter, not Esther Anuhya'

“Sympathy, if shown, would be misplaced and counterproductive and would send a wrong signal to society. Neither the parents of the innocent victim nor society would feel that justice has been done. Therefore the accused should be awarded the death penalty.” The final sentencing will take place on Friday.

"Exciting news! Mid-day is now on WhatsApp Channels Subscribe today by clicking the link and stay updated with the latest news!" Click here!

Mid-Day Web Stories

Mid-Day Web Stories

This website uses cookie or similar technologies, to enhance your browsing experience and provide personalised recommendations. By continuing to use our website, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy. OK