Why was the BMC unable to manage Tuesday's downpour effectively?

Sep 02, 2017, 16:29 IST | Debjani Paul, Rimita Majumder and Laxman Singh

The rainfall the Mumbai received on Tuesday, August 29 was merely one-third of what the city had witnessed on July 26, 2005, so why was the flooding just as bad this year? mid-day decodes the answer


Representational picture

It was like 26/7 all over again for Mumbai on Tuesday, as Mumbai drowned under nearly 300 mm of rainfall -- the worst downpour since the 2005 deluge. While the BMC is patting itself on the back for better disaster management this time around, the fact is, things could have been a lot worse. The rainfall on August 29 was merely one-third of what Mumbai had received on July 26, 2005, so why was the flooding just as bad this year?

New and improved system
While Mumbai’s disaster control unit was set up in 1999 but had a mere strength of 12 staffers. During the 2005 deluge, the small unit was overwhelmed by the sheer scale of the disaster. Learning from the tragedy of 26/7, the BMC set up a 24x7 Disaster Management Cell with a strength of 72 staffers working in three shifts around the clock. The Cell is equipped with 30 phone lines for its 1916 helpline, along with a GIS control centre, 58 wireless sets, 51 MTNL hotlines, HAM radios for back-up. It also gets a live feed from the city’s 4,500 CCTV cameras.

Also read - Can't control nature but haven't moved an inch: HC on Mumbai floods

#Fail, again
After 26/7, a fact-finding committee headed by hydrologist Madhav Chitale had recommended a complete overhaul of the city’s British-era drains, as well construction seven pumping stations. After 12 years, the project, named BRIMSTOWAD, is only 80% complete. The Mahul pumping station remains only on paper, as authorities cite land issues.

Also read - Mumbai rains: With risk of water borne diseases reigning high, BMC issues warning

Filthy drains were a major problem in 2005, and it was no different this year. After the Rs 150-crore desilting scam came to light in 2015-16, several contractors were penalised and blacklisted. This year, not a single contractor came forward for the job, forcing the BMC to do it with the help of local ward staffers and NGO workers. But it’s questionable how effective this was, without the right expertise.

One of the biggest causes of the 2005 floods was plastic garbage that blocked storm-water drains and natural waterways, including Mithi river. The Madhav Chitale panel had warned against the use of plastic, particularly the danger of littering it in open drains, but the civic body has failed to resolve this issue.

Lessons learnt
>> Disaster Cell issued early warnings about the rising water level during high tide
>> BMC advised offices to allow employees to leave early
>> In the evening, civic body warned commuters to stay home or in office to avoid getting stuck in the floods and traffic
>> BMC’s sister organisation, BEST Undertaking, pressed 100 extra services into operation to get people home
>> Mumbai Police was out all night, helping citizens in distress
>> 229 dewatering pumps were deployed; all pumping stations were operational to push water out faster
>> BMC issued a health advisory to boil drinking water, and take antibiotics after wading in floodwater


You may also like - Mumbai Rains photos: Heavy showers drown city
Mumbai Rains photos: Heavy showers drown city

Voices

'From 2005 to 2017, a lot has changed. Response is quick. It was not so earlier, due to limited resources. Roles of all agencies have been defined, and we have an SOP in place'
Mahesh Narvekar, chief officer, Disaster Management Cell

'It is crucial to keep drains and roads clean of plastic waste, which can block the rainwater from receding into the sea. This
is the responsibility of both the civic body and the citizens'
Madhav Chitale, water expert who led 26/7 fact-finding committee

Citizens say

Apurva Banthia,
Andheri resident
'I had a couple of meetings lined up, but I cancelled them. It had been raining all night and I knew that the trains would be affected. Hence, I stayed back and enjoyed my time at home. It was the best decision ever.'

Pranjali Salvi,
Malad resident
'In the afternoon, when BMC started issuing warnings, my boss and I picked up a couple of stranded people in our car and dropped them at different places. We managed to get to Juhu from Parel after six hours'

Dr Ashish Tiwari
Andheri resident
"Around 9 pm, we spotted many people stranded in Ghatkopar. We picked up a stranded 55-year-old woman and dropped her at Chakala on our way home to Andheri'

Go to top